Referenda and the Venezuelan Constitution

October 27, 2002

 


President Chavez regularly accuses the opposition of trying to stage a coup de etat and saying that a referendum to revoke his mandate may not be possible until August of 2003. The problem is that while the Constitution says in Article 72:


Todos los cargos y magistraturas de eleccin popular son revocables. Transcurrida la mitad del perodo para el cual fue elegido el funcionario, un nmero no menor del veinticinco (25) por ciento de los electores inscritos en la correspondiente circunscripcin, podr solicitar la convocatoria de un referendo para revocar su mandato


Which means All positions and magistratures which are popularly elected are revocable. After the midpoint of the term for which a functionary was elected, a number no less than than 25% of the registered voters may ask to have a referendum to revoke his mandate


 the problem is that Article 71 also says:


Las materias de especial trascendencia nacional podrn ser sometidas a referendo consultivo, por iniciativa del Presidente de la Repblica en Consejo de Ministros, por acuerdo de la Asamblea Nacional, aprobado por el voto de la mayora de los miembros de cada Cmara, o a solicitud de un nmero no menor del diez por ciento de los electores inscritos en el registro electoral nacional


 


Which means:


 


Matters of special national  transcendence may be subject to a consulting referendum , by initiative of the President in the Council with his Ministers, the National Assembly, approved by a majority or at the request of no less than 10% of the voters registered in the national electoral registry


 


This article is the one that the opposition is using to call for a consultive referendum on whether Hugo Chavez should resign or not. The difference is just that it would not be binding if Chvez lost. But it certainly is a legal procedure that would undermine Chavez ability to govern if he were to lose it by a large margin, which we think he will. In fact, if the opposition convinced 50% of the Deputies in the National Asembly that would be sufficient to hold the referendum. This may yet happen.


 


A final comment is that while Hugo Chavez says the revocatory referendum may take place only after August 2003, this is not the case. The Venezuelan Supreme Court ruled that Chvez new term began in January 2001, thus a revocatory referendum could only take place after January 2004. This is part of the Chavez lore, where he said something once and has become the truth even if it isn’t.


 


(Warning: The articles of the Constitution cited above may depend on the version you consult, yes there are multiple versions of the Venezuelan Constitution. If you use Google, the first one says they are article 75 and 74, the next one 72 and 71 and they are both Government websites. Thanks to Antonio Guzman Blanco for reminding me that one has to be extremely careful with this.)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 11,711 other followers

%d bloggers like this: